Application effect and limitation of AHP as a research methodology -A comparison of 3 statistical technique for evaluating MIS success factor-

AHP 기법의 적용효과및 한계점에 관한 연구 -MIS 성공요인평가를 위한 3가지 통계기법 비교중심-

  • 윤재곤 (대구효성가톨릭대학교 경영학과)
  • Published : 1996.12.01

Abstract

Biases and errors in the human being's reasoning process have been studied continuously by the researchers, especially psychlogists and social scientists. These bias phenomenon is classified on the basis of the origin, i. e. motivation and cognition. Furthermore the necessity of research on the bias in the management and management information system areas in increased more and more recently, which have their academic backgrounds in the psychology and social science. The biased information stream is transformed into the systematic error due to the motivation and cognitive bias of human-being, then its resulting phenomena are as follows; 1. the availability of salient information 2. preconceived ideas or theories about peoples and event 3. anchoring and perseverence phenomena. In order to reduce the information errors, Satty suggested the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) that is the subject of this paper and that is widely used for evaluation of complex decision making alternatives. THerefore this paper studies AHP's effects and its limitations in applying to the management area. Thus this paper compared the performances of the 3 models : 1 the traditional additive regression model. 2 regression model using the factor score, and 3 the regression model with AHP. As a result, 3 models produce the different outcomes.

Keywords

References

  1. 품질관리학회지 품질기능전개와 AHP기법을 이용한 기능평가 박노국;문희영;송문익
  2. 한국경영과학회지 AHP 가중치 결정에서의 전문가 의견종합방법 김성천;어하준
  3. 회계학연구 사원부정의 발상원인과 방지방법의 중요성에 대한 내부감사 및 판단에 관한연구:AHP 김영태
  4. 한국경영과학회지 불확실한 상황하에서 다목표 R&D투자계획수립에 관한연구 이영찬;민재형
  5. 한국경영과학회지 한국의 생산 자동화 기술수준 위촉 황규승
  6. European Journal of Social Psychology v.13 Bias and Error in Human Judgment Kruglanski Arie W.;Icek Ajzen
  7. Organizational Characteristics and MIS success in the con Raymond,L.