Evaluation of the Validity of a Simple Screening Test Developed for Identifying Korean Elderly at Risk of Undernutrition

우리 나라 노인의 영양부족위험 진단을 위해 개발된 간이조사표의 타당성 평가

  • 이정원 (충남대학교 소비자생활정보학과) ;
  • 김경은 (충남대학교 소비자생활정보학과) ;
  • 김기남 (충북대학교 식품영양학과) ;
  • 현태선 (충북대학교 식품영양학과) ;
  • 현화진 (추부대학교 생명자원학부 식품영양전공) ;
  • 박영숙 (순천향대학교 응용과학부 식품영양전공)
  • Published : 2000.12.01

Abstract

This study intended to evaluate the validity of the simple nutrition screening test that had been developed with the elderly living in Cheongju as a subject. Nutrition screening score(NSS) and reference standards for nutritional and health status(nutrient intakes, mean adequacy ratio, perceive health, and serum albumin, hematocrit, and hemoglobin) were estimated by using the date obtained in 1996 from the 174 elderly living in Taejon, Statistical analysis showed significant correlations between mean adequacy ratio(MAR) and NSS(r=0.341) and also between NSS and biological indices such as albumin and hematocrit, Around 65-75% of the elderly with perceive health and low level of serum albumin, hemoglobin and hematocrit had NSS$\leq$ll. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive values(PPV) were calculated from the crosstabulation of the three categories of NSS(high, moderate, and low nutritional risk) and low categories MAR(< 0.75, undernutrition;$\geq$0.75, normal) to validate the cut-off point for high or low nutritional risk by NSS. It was suggested that point l1 was appropriate as a criterion to determine high risk of undernutrition, but point 16 was better than 17 as criterion to determine low nutritional risk in the Taejon elderly. When point ll was used as a criterion of high nutritional risk, sensitivity, specificity, and PPV are 59.5, 60.5 and 82.1 respectively. When point 16 was used as a criterion of low nutritional risk, sensitivity, specificity, and PPV are 25.6, 95.4, and 64.7%, respectively. In conclusion, nutrition screening test that had been developed can be a simple, easy, and proper instrument to classify the high risk group of undernutrition. A further validation study seems to be required among other groups of individuals for the screening test to the finalized as a more valid instrument identifying Korean elderly at nutrition and health risk(Korean J Nutrition 33(8) : 864-872, 2000)

Keywords

References

  1. World and Korean Vital Statistics The Office of Statistics
  2. Korean J Community Nutr v.2 no.4 Nutritional status of the elderly living in Cheongju-I. Health related habits, dietary behaviors and nutrient intakes Kim KN;Lee JW;Park YS;Hyun TS
  3. Korean J Community Nutr v.4 no.1 Nutrient intakes and health-related behaviors of the elderly in rural area Park YS;Kim S;Park KS;Lee JW;Kim KN
  4. Korean J Community Nutr v.1 no.2 Current nutritional status by different age group Park HR
  5. Korean J Community Nutr v.4 no.1 Strategies to improve elderly nutrition- Comparisons of dietary behavior according to the mean nutrient adequacy ratio Yim KS
  6. J Korean Soc Food Sci Nutr v.25 no.6 A study in meal management and nutrient intake of the elderly Hong SM;Choi SY
  7. The J Korean Public Health Assoc v.14 no.2 The relationship of ecological factors to the nutrient intake of elderly in Pyongtaek area Park MO;Lee JW;Lee BK
  8. Korean J Community Nutr v.1 no.1 Nutritional and health status of Korean elderly from low income, urban area and improving effect of meal service in nutritional and health status.- I. Anthropometric measurements and nutrient intakes Son SM;Park YJ;Koo JO;Mo SM;Yoon HY;Sung CJ
  9. Korean J Nut v.28 The Nutritional status of the female elderly residents in nursing home- I. Nutritional and biochemical health status Song YS;Chung HK;Cho MS
  10. Korean J Community Nutr v.3 no.4 Nutritional intake status of the elderly taking free congregate lunch meals compared to the middle-income class elderly Lee JW;Kim KA;Lee MS
  11. Ann Nutr Metab v.36 Malnutrition in geriatric patients: Diagnostic and prognostic significance of nutritional parameters Volkert D;Kruse W;Oster P;Schliert G
  12. Health Services Research v.20 no.6 Further assessment of the reliability andvalidity of a nutritional risk index: Analysis of a three-wave panel study of elderly adults Wolinsky FD;Coe RM;Chaves MN;Prendergast JM;Miller DK
  13. Korean J Community Nutr v.3 no.6 Nutrition assessment tools and indices for nutrition screening Lee JW
  14. Am J Public Health v.83 no.7 Nutrition and health risks in the elderly. The nutrition screening initiative Posner BM;Jette AM;Smith KW;Miller DR
  15. The mini nutritional assessment: MNA. Nutrition in the elderly(3rd ed.) Vellas BJ;GuiGoz Y;Garry PJ;Albarede JL
  16. J Am Diet Assoc v.88 no.2 Nutritional risk screening. Development of a standardized protocol using dietetic technicians Hedberg AM;Nelda G;Irene JT;Susan WW;Martha LG;Lutz AL
  17. J Am Diet Assoc v.95 no.4 Field trial affirms value of determining nutrition-related problems of free-living elderly Spangler AA;Eigenbrod JS
  18. J Am Diet Assoc v.92 no.2 Nutrition screening initiative: Development and implementation of the public awareness checklist and screening tools White LV;Dwyer JT;Posner BM;Ham RJ;Lipschitz DA;Wellman NS
  19. Korean J Community Nutr v.5 no.3 Development of a simple screening test for identifying Korean elderly at risk of undernutrition Kim KN;Hyun TS;Lee JW
  20. Dietary life and diseases of Koreans Paik HY;Moon HK;Choi YS;Ahn YO;Lee HK;Lee SW
  21. Epidemiology Gordis L
  22. Am J Public Health v.72 Self-rated health: a predictor of mortality among the elderly Mossey JM;Shapiro E
  23. Recommended Dietary Allowances for Koreans(6th revision) The Korean Nutrition society
  24. Nutritional Assessments Lee JW;Lee MS;Kim JH;Son SM;Lee BS
  25. J Am Diet Assoc v.97 no.7 Nutrition screening initiative checklist may be a better awareness/educational tool than a screening one Sahyoun NR;Jacques PF;Dallal GE;Russell RM