A Study on the Budget Allocation to Public Health Programs Using Matrix Delphi Technique

매트릭스 구성 델파이법을 이용한 공공보건사업 예산배분 연구

  • Published : 2000.12.01

Abstract

This study was conducted to get a resonable set of budget allocation to public health programs. Matrix Delphi technique was used to obtain the logic of study results and eventually to form a human model which could predict opinion of professionals on budget allocation. Thirty-two professionals in academic and governmental area responded to Delphi survey. Questionnaire was developed using matrix formation, and the matrix was formed by 6 decision criteria on budget allocation and 26 public health programs. The decision criteria are as following: size of problem(morbidity), severity of problem, social equity, importance of prevention, technical feasibility and efficiency of programs. Severity of problem dropped out of the model because it had significant correlation with the size of problem. A total score of each program was obtained by weighting the relative importance of each criteria which also were given by survey respondents. These total scores indicate that the most important public health program is vaccination for infants and children in terms of budget allocation. Monitoring communicable diseases, mental health program, and anti-smoking program are the next. In addition, respondents were asked of the desirable budget size of each program. The result was rearranged by multiple regression model using the scores of each decision criteria. In this process, the current budget size of central government was provided to the respondents, and included in the model. h set of desirable budgets modified using tile model was obtained. Considering the current size of budget, tile results of the model is very different from that of the total score. Managing dementia is ranked the first. Health promotion program for the elderly, rehabilitation of the disabled and monitoring communicable diseases are the next. The need to increase the budget of vaccination for the infants and children was not found as so high. The matrix structure in Delphi survey gave us the precise basis to make optimal decision, and made it possible to develop an opinion predicting model. However the plentifulness and diversity of professional opinions were not fully obtained due to the limited number of decision criteria.

Keywords

References

  1. 우리 나라에서 보건의료의 공공성 향상을 위한 바람직한 보건소 역할 설정에 관한 연구 : 델파이 기법의 적용 강민종
  2. 우리 나라 암 연구수준의 평가와 암 연구인력 훈련요구의 예측 : 델파이법의 적용 강영호
  3. 국민보건연구소 연구논총 v.5 no.1 국민건강증진사업 개발을 위한 소고 김공현
  4. 과학기술예측조사의 방법론과 활용방안 김형수
  5. 정책분석론 노화준
  6. 정책평가론 노화준
  7. 지역단위 건강증진사업 실태와 개선방안 변종화;김진수;김은주
  8. 국민건강증진기금 사업의 운영 및 평가체계 개발 변종화;문상식;이주열;남정자;한영자(등)
  9. 한국건강증진학회지 v.1 no.1 국민건강증진기금 사업의 방향 변종화;이주열
  10. 건강증진사업 실무자 교육 · 훈련교재 보건복지부
  11. 정책평가론 비둥
  12. 정책평가론 비둥(Vedung E.);이경옥(역)
  13. 보건복지포럼 노인보건사업의 정책방향 선우덕
  14. 한국의료 QA학회지 v.20 no.1 Delphi를 이용한 일차의료 고혈압 진료 지침 개발 양윤준;홍명호
  15. 정책평가를 위한 새로운 모형 이진주;서건수
  16. 지역단위 공공보건의료기관 기능 개편방안 장원기;김진순;박영택;이우백
  17. 보건행정학회지 v.7 no.2 보건소 기능의 중요도에 따른 자원배분의 적절성 평가 전기홍;송미숙;김찬호
  18. 21세기 보건소를 위한 보건소 업무 표준화 및 교육 · 훈련 프로그램 개발 기초연구 정두채;송건용;이정자;김성옥;강민종(등)
  19. 정핵학원론 정정길
  20. 정책평가의 이론과 실제 - 기관평가제 접근모형과 전략 차의환
  21. Oregon's Experiment. Reforming Health Care : The Philosophy and Practice of International Health Reform Branningan M;Seedhouse D(ed.)
  22. Technological Forecasting and Social Change v.16 Individual Stability in Delphi Studies Chaffin WW;Talley WK
  23. Priority Setting : The Health Care Debate Coast J
  24. Health Policy v.29 Core Services and Priority-Setting : the New Zealand Experience Cumming J
  25. Technological Forecasting and Social Change v.13 Stability and Agreement Criteria for the Termination of Delphi Studies Dajani JS;Sincoff MZ;Tally WK
  26. American Political Science Review v.51 Predicting Supreme Court Decisions Mathematically : A Quantitative Analysis of The 'Right to Counsel' cases Kort F
  27. Technological Forecasting v.1 The Lognormality of Delphi Estimates Martino JP
  28. Thechnological Forecasting and Social Change v.10 Using the Delphi Method to Assess Community Health Needs Schoeman ME;Mahajan V