Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society (한국도서관정보학회지)

Korean Library and Information Science Society (한국도서관정보학회)
권호 표지

Analysis of Digital Achilles Tendon of Scholarly Journals

학술지의 디지털 아킬레스건 분석

  • 윤희윤 (대구대학교 문헌정보학과)
  • Published : 2003.12.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

Nowadays many academic libraries have considered and some have implemented the just-in-time(access) approach to collection development especially of scholarly journals. The adaption of the scholarly electronic journal based on access paradigm has brought a number of advantages and disadvantages to academic libraries. Electronic journals have promised rapid delivery of the latest research to the desktop through the ubiquitous platform of the Internet. But the promise of the e-journal is not yet a reality, and there are many misconceptions about what is actually available today. The objective of this paper is to analyse the probabilities of digital achilles tendon of scholarly journals resulting from a decline of purchase power, absence of selection(evaluation) criteria, superfluities and abuses of impact factor, access paradigm and halo effects, mismatching of demand-supply, md insufficiency in subject gateway functions.

오늘날 많은 학술도서관이 장서개발에 접근패러다임을 적극적으로 대입하고 있다. 그 대표적인 사례가 전자잡지의 수용이며, 그것의 가장 큰 이점은 최신의 연구논문이 인터넷에 산재하는 플랫폼을 통하여 데스크탑으로 전달된다는 점이다. 그럼에도 불구하고 아직은 전자잡지가 구독(라이센스)가격, 인쇄잡지의 지속적인 생존력, 아카이빙, 접근 및 이용이 편의성 등의 난제로 인하여 학술커뮤니케이션의 주류매체로 공인 받지 못하고 있을 뿐만 아니라 많은 곡해마저 양산하고 있다. 이에 본 연구는 학술지의 구매력 저하, 선택(평가)기준의 부재, 영향계수의 가외성과 남용, 디지털 접근패러다임과 후광효과, 전자잡지 수급의 부 정합, 주제 게이트웨이 기능의 부실 등의 측면에서 디지털 아킬레스건의 개연성을 분석하고자 한다.

Keywords

References

  1. 學術情報の流通基盤の充實について(平成14年 3月12日) 科學技術·學術審議會
  2. 情報管理 v.45 no.11 電子ジセナル一部賣りの動向 原田英二(外)
  3. 도서관 v.56 no.3 국가도서관의 전자출판물 수집 및 보존방안 윤희윤
  4. 한국문헌정보학회지 v.36 no.2 국내외 전자출판물 납본제도의 분석 윤희윤
  5. 國會圖書館報 v.39 no.5 도서관의 도플갱어와 쿠오 바디스 윤희윤
  6. 國會圖書館報 v.38 no.1 도서관 장서관리의 대립적 패러다임 분석 윤희윤
  7. 정보관리연구 v.33 no.4 디지털시대의 정보자원 개발의 오류와 난제 윤희윤
  8. 장서관리론 윤희윤
  9. 정보자료 수집규모 최적화 연구 윤희윤
  10. The Newsletter for Journal Publishers v.4 15th Annual Study of Journal prices for Scientific and Medical Society Journals Allen Press, Inc.
  11. Perspectives in Publishing v.1 Impact Factors : Use and Abuse Amin, M.;M. Mabe
  12. The Scale of Future Piblishing in Digital and Conventional Formats : A Report to the British Library Policy Unit by Mark Bide Bide, Mark(et al.)
  13. Library Trends v.50 no.3 Ranking of Nations and Heightened Competition in Matthew Core Journals : Two Faces of Mattew Effect for Countries Boniz;Manfred
  14. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Pittsburgh Planning for the Balance between Print and Electronic Journals in the Hybrid Digital Library : Lessions Learned from Large ARL Libraries Brody;Fern Elise
  15. College & Research Libraries v.63 no.6 Patterns in Electronic Journal Usage : Challenging the Composition of Geographic Consortia Davis, Philip M. https://doi.org/10.5860/crl.63.6.484
  16. Liber Quarterly v.10 Scientific Information : A Partnership between the Library and the Academic Community Dekeyser, Raf https://doi.org/10.18352/lq.7602
  17. College & Research Libraries v.58 no.1 Access vs. Ownership : Do We Have to Make a Choices? Kane, Lana Townsend
  18. Serials Review v.28 no.2 The Endangered Science Journal Collection in a Medium-Sized Academic Library : A Comparative Analysis Kuma;John https://doi.org/10.1016/S0098-7913(02)00171-5
  19. American Economic Review v.92 no.1 Journal Pricing and Mergers : A Portfolio Approach McCabe, M.J. https://doi.org/10.1257/000282802760015702
  20. Library Hi Tech v.17 no.1 Seven Years of Tracking Electronic Publishing : The ARL Directory of Electronic Journals, Newsletters and Academic Discussion Lists Mogge, Dru https://doi.org/10.1108/07378839910267154
  21. D-Lib Magazine v.8 no.10 Comparing Library and User Related Costs of Print and Electronic Journal Collections : A First Step Towards a Comprehensive Analysis Montgomery, Carol Hansen;Donald W. King
  22. Issues in Science and Technology Librarianship v.30 E-Journal Bundling and Its Impact on Academic Libraries : Some Early Results Nabe, Jonathan
  23. Library Trends v.50 no.3 Journal Evalution : Technical and Practical Issues Rousseau, Ronald
  24. E-Journal User Study : Report of First Survey;E-Journal User Study : Report of the Second Survey : The Feature User Study Stanford University Library
  25. Learned Publishing v.15 Reading Behaviour and Electronic Journals Temopir, Carlo;Donald W. King https://doi.org/10.1087/095315102760319215
  26. Library Journals v.125 no.12 Moving Toward Electronic Journals Tenopir, Carol
  27. The Electronic Library v.19 no.6 Content Management and the Future of Academic Libraries Wu, Yuhfen Diana;Mengxiong Liu https://doi.org/10.1108/02640470110412044
  28. Library Trends v.47 no.4 Scholarly Use of Internet-Based Electronic Resources : A Survey Report Zhang, Yin