Korean Journal of Community Nutrition (대한지역사회영양학회지)

The Korean Society of Community Nutrition (대한지역사회영양학회)
권호 표지

Development of Performance Indicators Based on Balanced Score Card for School Food Service Facilities

균형성과표(BSC)개념을 적응한 학교급식 운영성과 측정지표 개발

  • 곽동경 (연세대학교 생활과학대학 식품영양학과) ;
  • 장혜자 (수원여자대학 식품과학부 식품영양과) ;
  • 송지영 ((주)영진약품)
  • Published : 2005.12.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study raised the necessity of developing performance indicators for measuring the management efficiency and effectiveness of school food service, and as a means of helping its implementation, a balanced score card (BSC) approach developed by Norton and Kaplan was adopted. This study established BSC in seven phases through literature: Phase 1 Defining a school food service and the scope of working activities, Phase 2 Establishing the vision of a school food service, Phase 3 Setting strategic goals, Phase 4 Identifying critical success factors (CSFs), Phase 5 Developing Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), Phase 6 Extracting cause and effect relationship, and Phase 7 Completing a preliminary BSC. The preliminary BSC was fumed into a survey, which was administered to food service related people working at the Office of Education and School Food Service including 16 offices,209 dietitians, 48 school administrators both from self-operated and contract-managed, and 9 experts in areas related to school food service. They were asked questions about strategies from 4 different perspectives,12 CSFs, 39 KPls, and the cause and effect relationships among them. As a result, among the CSFs based on 4 different perspectives, all factors other than ' zero sum on profit/loss ' from the financial perspective turned out to be valid. In terms of KPIs, manufacturing cost percentages, casualty loss count/reduction rates, school foodervice participation rates, and sales goal achievement rates were found to be valid from the financial perspective, while student satisfaction index, faculty satisfaction index, leftover ratio, nutrition educational performance count, index of evaluating nutrition education, customer claim count/reduction rate, handling customer claim count/reduction rate, and parent satisfaction index were found to be valid from the customers' perspective. Besides, nutritional requirement sufficient ratio, nutritional management score, food poisoning outbreak count, employee safety accident count, sanitary inspection assessment index, meals per labor hour (productivity index), computerization ratio, operational management index, and purchase management assessment index were also found to be valid from the perspective of internal business processes. From the perspective of innovation and learning, employee turnover ratio/rate of absenteeism, annual education and training count, employee satisfaction index, human resource management assessment index, annual menu-related customer feedback, food service information index for employees and parents/schools were also found to be valid. The significance of this study is to present indices for measuring overall performance of school lunch food service operations without putting any limitation on types of school food service management, and to help correctly assess the contribution of the current types of school food service management to schools and students. (Korean J Community Nutrition 10(6) : $905\∼919$, 2005)

Keywords

References

  1. An YS, Kim HS(2001): Digital economy: an empirical analysis on the performance factors of software venture business in the perspectives of BSC and subjective performance. Information Systems Review 3(1): 31-46
  2. Chang HJ (1996): Assessment of Main Management Components for successful university foodservice operations and development of foodservcie management standards. Yonsei University
  3. Choe SH, Kim SH, Kwak TK (2003): The survey of perception on obstacles in implementing generic HACCP plan for school foodservice operations. Journal of the Korean Dietetic Association 9(3): 209-218
  4. 대구달성초등학교(2000): 학교급식운영평가방안연구-시범사업보고-. 한국학교보건학회 13(1): 49-62
  5. Eo GH, Ryu K, Park SJ, Kwak TK (2000): Need assessments of HACCP- based sanitation training program in elementary school foodservice operations based on sanitation knowledge test of employees. Journal of the Korean Dietetic Association 7(1): 56-64
  6. Gregory AD, Bruce W (2000): Implementing a balanced scorecard approach to managing hotel operation. Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Adminstration Quarterly 2: 92-107
  7. Griffin B, Dunn JM, Irvin J, Speranza I (2001): Standards of professional practices for dietetics professionals in management and foodservice settings. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 101(8): 944-946 https://doi.org/10.1016/S0002-8223(01)00234-6
  8. Hong WS, Chang HJ (2003): The relationship between food service satisfaction and plate wastes in elementary school students. Korean Journal of Food and Cookery Science 19(3): 390-395
  9. Hopf RH, Litman DJ, Pratsch L, Ustad IM, Welch RA, Tychan TJ, Denett PA (2000): Guide to a balanced scorecard performance management methodology. Procurement Executives' Association
  10. Joe YY (2001a): 급식평가(I). 국민영양 11: 48-49
  11. Joe YY (2001b): 급식평가(II). 국민영양 12: 38-39
  12. Johnson BC, Chambers MJ (2000): Expert panel identifies activities and performance measures for foodservice benchmarking. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 100(6): 692-695 https://doi.org/10.1016/S0002-8223(00)00201-7
  13. Kaplan RS, Norton DP (1992): The balanced scorecard measures that drive performance. Harvard Business Review Jan, pp.71-79
  14. Kaplan RS, Norton DP (1993): Putting the balanced scorecard to work. Harvard Business Review Sep, pp.134-142
  15. Kim CR (1994): SAS라는 통계상자. Data Research Publishing Co., Seoul
  16. Kim HK, Sung ES (2001): BSC 실천 매뉴얼. (주) 시그마인사이트컴
  17. Kim SH (2001): 학교급식운영실태 분석 및 발전방안연구. 교육인적 자원부 2001년도 정책연구과제
  18. Kwak TK (1999): Instituting a HACCP System Model to School Foodservices. 1999 Ministry of Education and Human Resources Development Report
  19. Kwak TK, Chang HJ, Lee NY (2003): A study on cost analyses and an efficient financial management in self-operated and contract-managed secondary school foodservices. Korean Journal of Nutrition 36(10): 1083-1093
  20. Kwak TK, Hong WS, Moon HK, Ryu K, Chang HJ (2001): Assessment of sanitary management practices of school foodservice operations in Seoul. Journal of Food Hygiene and Safety 16(3): 168-177
  21. Kwak TK, Ryu ES, Lee HS, Hong WS, Chang HJ (2001): Foodservice Management. Shinkwang Publishing Co., Seoul
  22. Lee CS (2001): The validity of balanced scored card in medium sized hospitals. Yonsei University
  23. Lee MU, Jeon JW (2005): An empirical study on the effectiveness of BSC to measure service quality performance- on based hotel industry. Journal of Korean Tourism Policy 11(1): 191-210
  24. Lee OH, Chang HS (1999): Body composition and eating behavior of rural middle school students provided with and without national school lunch program. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association 11(2): 39-50
  25. Ministry of Education and Human Resources Development (2003): Statement of school foodservice. Ministry of Education and Human Resources Development
  26. Moon HK (2003): Analysis of menu in school food service: comparing the use of traditional menu between 1995 and 2001. Journal of the Korean Dietetic Association 9(1): 47-56
  27. Olive NG, Roy J, Wetter M. 번역 송경근(2000): BSC 구축 & 실행사례. (주) 한언
  28. Reynolds D (1999): Managed-service companies: The new scorecard for on-site foods service. Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administation Quarterly 37(3): 88-95
  29. SMOE (2003): Operation manual for school foodservice. Seoul Metropolitan Office of Education
  30. The American School Food Service Association (1995): Key to Excellence America School Foodservice Association, Denver, Colo
  31. Yang IS, Han SO (1993): Job satisfaction and its relationship to job characteristics of school foodservice dietitians. Korean J Dietary Culture 8(1): 11-19
  32. Yang IS, Lee SJ, Cha JA (2000): Development of Quality Management Standards and Evaluation Tool for the Quality Improvement of Hospital Food and Nutrition. Services Korean Journal of Nutrition 33(5): 548-553
  33. Yi BS, Yang IS, Kim KI (1998): Development of standardized staffing indices in school foodservice systems. Korean Journal of Nutrition 31(3): 354-362
  34. Yoo JI (2001): Development of a performance measurement system for the perioperative nursing unit using the balanced score card. Yonsei University
  35. Yoon J, Messersmith AM (2002): Foodservice systems management competencies of Korean dietitians: Usage, perceived importance, and educational preparation. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 103(5): 710-715