Journal of architectural history (건축역사연구)

Korean Association of Architectural History (한국건축역사학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Reconsideration of the Athens Charter(1931)

아테네 헌장(1931)의 재고

  • 최병하 (계명대학교 산업기술연구소)
  • Received : 2012.02.15
  • Accepted : 2012.07.20
  • Published : 2012.08.31
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This paper is to review the conclusions of the Athens conference that has so far contributed to the conservation world. It is normally called the conclusions of the Athens conference as the Athens charter. But the conclusions of the Athens are not as same as the Athens Charter regarding the contents. The former had more valuable contents than the latter regarding historic monuments. And the report of the Athens conference including 56 articles and 500 pages with 55 photos was published in 1933 by the International Museums Office. But little attention has been given to the report of the Athens conference. Therefore the point I want to make is to review to the report in order to understand the agenda of the conference and to examine the Anastylosis in Acropolis. In conclusion, these agendas and the articles in the report show us that the conference was sort of milestone with some advanced modern philosophical and technical concepts about conservation and restoration of historic monuments. Also when the term of anastylosis turns to reconstruction in archaeological sites, we are going to face with the problems of authenticity.

Keywords

References

  1. Office International des Musees, La Conservation des Monuments d'Art et d'Histoire, Paris, 1933
  2. Francoise Choay, La Conference d'Athenes, Sur la conservation artistique et historique des monuments(1931), Les Editions de l'imprimeur, 2002
  3. Francoise Choay, The invention of the historic monument, Cambridge university press, 2001
  4. G. Baldwin Brown, M.A., The Care of ancient monuments, An Account of the legislative and other measures adopted in European countries for protecting ancient monuments and objects and scenes of natural beauty, and for preserving the aspect of historical cities, Cambridge at the university press, 1905
  5. A. R. Powys, Repair of ancient buildings, J.M. Dent & sons Ltd., 1929
  6. Paul Leon, Les monuments historiques: conservation, restauration, Paris, 1917
  7. Paul Leon, La vie des monuments Francais destruction Restauration, Editions A. ET J. PICARD ET CIE, Paris, 1951
  8. Ceschi, C., Teoria e storia del restauro, Bulzoni, Rome, 1970
  9. Nicolas Balanos, Les monuments de L'Acropole, Relevement et conservation, Paris, 1936
  10. Camillo Boito, Conservation ou restaurer, Les dilemmes du patrimoine, Les editions de I'Imprimeur, 2000
  11. 유카 요킬레토 지음, 최병하 옮김, 건축문화유산의 보존과 역사, 과거와 현재, 기문당, 2009
  12. Rosalia Varoli-Piazza, Riflessioni sulle Carte, Raccomandazioni e Documenti internazionali, Monumenti in bronzo all'aperto: esperienze di conservazione a confronto, Nardini Editore, 2004, p.24
  13. Cristina Iamandi, The Charters of Athens of 1931 and 1933, Coincidence, controversy and convergence, Conservation and management of Archaeological sites, vol.2, 1997, p.17-28 https://doi.org/10.1179/135050397793138934
  14. Rosa Anna Genovese, Sopra alcuni contributi metodologici e tecnici offerti in occasione della conferenza di Atene(1931), Restauro, no.43, 1979, p.77-134
  15. Andrzei Tomaszewski, From Athens 1931 to Venice 1964. History and actuality, Proceedings of the international conference of the ICOMOS International Scientific Committee for the Theory and the Philosophy of Conservation and Restoration, 2008 Vienna, Austria, p.107-114
  16. G. Giovannoni, La Conferenza internazionale di Atene pel restauro dei monumenti, Bollettino d'Arte, Fasc. IX, Roma, 1932, p.408-420
  17. L. Hautecoeur, Conference internationale d'experts pour la protection et la conservation des monuments d'art et d'histoire, Gazette des Beaux Arts, Pari, 1932, no106, p.161-163
  18. Cevat Erder, Our architectural heritage: from consciousness to conservation, museums and monuments XX, UNESCO, 1986, p.102
  19. L. Santoro, Il concetto di restauro: contributi metodologici e tecnici (1880-1940), Restauro, no.43, 1979, p.38

Cited by

  1. International cooperations for the Safeguarding on Angkor during two decades - by analysis of Tokyo, Paris and Angkor Declarations - vol.23, pp.3, 2014, https://doi.org/10.7738/JAH.2014.23.3.021