Journal of Korean Society of Rural Planning (농촌계획)

Korean Society of Rural Planning (한국농촌계획학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Study on Affecting Factor-Construction of Collaborative Planning Process and Effect on Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project

농촌마을종합개발사업의 협력적 계획과정과 계획효과의 영향구조 분석

  • Kim, Tae-Gu (Korea Rural Community Corporation) ;
  • Lee, Seong-Keun (Dept. of Regional Development and Welfare Administration, Yeungnam Univ.)
  • 김태구 (한국농어촌공사) ;
  • 이성근 (영남대학교 지역 및 복지행정학과)
  • Received : 2014.05.13
  • Accepted : 2014.05.20
  • Published : 2014.06.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study aims to analyze the affecting factors-construction of collaborative planning process and effect on Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project. To this end, targeting the 36 districts which were selected for 2004 Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project and completed their 2010 5-year projects, components of collaborative planning process and planning effect will be drawn and the affecting factors-construction of collaborative planning and effect on Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project will be analyzed below. According to the results of this study, the affecting factors of collaborative planning process of Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project on planning effect, The level of effect of individual component on endogenous variable appeared greatest mostly in the upper groups. In terms of the level of individual component effect, social learning process and interaction among participants affected greatest. The process of Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project is evaluated that it reflected collaborative planning theory of Healey enough. Therefore, in the course of Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project progress, collaborative planning model must pass social learning process and interaction among participants which are the most important components out of collaborative planning process as we saw in the upper groups. And in order to maximize the performance and results of Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project, the following sequential affecting factors model as Figure 7 must be suggested as optimal collaborative planning models of Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project. Based on the results of the study, the policy implication was drawn as follows. First, systematic supplementations in the form of a consultative body are required to perform Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project efficiently. Second, network needs to be built among different participants in Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project process. Third, systematic mechanism is required to improve social learning among different participants. Fourth, systematic rearrangement is required to guarantee the residents' realistic participation in the course of Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project process.

Keywords

References

  1. 권원용, 서순탁 (역), 2004, 협력적 계획, 한울아카데미(Healey, P., 1997, Collaboration Planning: Shaping Places in Fragmented Societies, London: Macmillan).
  2. 길종백, 2004, 지역복원사업에서 지방정부와 주민과의 협력을 통한 정책형성: 우림시장 활성화 사업의 전개과정을 중심으로, 한국행정연구 13(3).
  3. 김렬, 성도경, 이환범, 이수창, 2008, 사회과학연구 및 논문작성을 위한 통계분석의 이해 및 활용, 도서출판 대명.
  4. 나태준, 박재희, 2004, 갈등해결의 제도적 접근: 현행 갈등관련 제도분석 및 대안, 한국행정연구원.
  5. 부만근, 2000, 한국지방자치론, 제주대학교 출판부.
  6. 윤원근, 2004, 농촌계획의 여건변화와 방향정립, 농어촌과 환경 14(1).
  7. 홍성만, 2004, 협력적 로컬거버넌스의 대두: 대포천 수질개선을 둘러싼 정부-주민간 협력적 로컬거버넌스 분석, 한국행정학회 하계학술대회 발표논문집.
  8. Cho, J. H. & Y. G. Kim., 2008, Grounded Theoric Interpretation of Residents' Conflict Occurred in Process of Promoting a Rural Community Development Project: Focused on the Case of the Agricultural Experience Villages, Journal of Korea Society of Rural Planning, v.10 n.4.
  9. Fischler, R., 2000, Communicative planning theory: A Foucauldian assessment, Journal of Planning Education and Reseach, Vol. 19.
  10. Forester, J., 1999, The Deliberative Practitioner: Encouraging Participatory Planning Process, Cambridge Mass: The MIT Press.
  11. Healey, P., 1997, Collaborative Planning: Shaping Places in Fragmented Societies, London: Macmillan.
  12. Healey, P., 1998, The British planning system and managing the urban environment, Town Planning Review.
  13. Innes, J. E. & D. E. Booher, 1999, Planning Institutions in the Network Society Theory for Collaborative Planning, Working Paper 99-05, Berkeley, CA: Institute of Urban and Regional Development, University of California.
  14. Innes, J. E. & D. E. Booher, 2000, Public Participation in Planning: New Strategies for the 21st Century, Paper prepared for the annual conference of the Association of Collegiate School of Planning, November.
  15. Innes, J. E., 1996, Planning through consensus building: A new view of the comprehensive planning ideal, Journal of the American Planning Association.
  16. Jang, O. Y., 2004, Historic Preservation Planning through Communication and Collaboration, The Ph. D. thesis at the University of Seoul.
  17. Ju, D. J. & J. M. Kim., 2004, Exploring Methodologies for Facilitating Residents' Participation at Comprehensive Rural Village Development Projects in Korea, Korea journal of Ag Extension, v.11 n2.
  18. Kim, D. W., 2000, Application of A Collaborative Planning Model as A Social Learning Process: focusing of Consensus Conference, The M. A. thesis at the Seoul National University.
  19. Kim, G. S., 2009, A Study on the Architectural Planning Characteristics of the Rural Village Synthesis Development Project in Korea, Community development review No.71.
  20. Kim, K. R. & Y. S. Choi., S. K. Hong., 2006, Development of an interim evaluation system for integrated rural village cluster development project, Journal of Korea Society of Rural Planning, v.12 n.2.
  21. Kim, Y. G. & J. H. Cho., J. S. Shim., 2008, Perception of the Resident Conflict in Agricultural Joint Business Management, journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture, Article 36(3).
  22. Lee, D. K. et al., 2005, A Study on Assessment and Classification about Rural Landscape Resources: Centered on Comprehensive Development Project of Rural Village, Journal of Korea Society of Rural Planning, v.11 n.2
  23. Lee, H. J., 2009, Changes in Rural Policy Paradigm and Rural Development Project in Korea: A Study based on Integrated Rural Village Development Project, The Korean Rural Sociological Society v.19 n.1.
  24. Lee, H. K., 2009, A Case Study in the Redevelopment Conflict of the North Harbor, Busan Port, whthin a Collaborative Planning Perspective, The Ph. D. thesis at the University of Seoul.
  25. Lee, H. S., 2006, An Analysis on Priority Determining Criteria among Integrated Development Projects in Rural Villages Using AHP, Journal of Agricultural Management and Policy, v.33 n.1.
  26. Lee, K. H. & K. H. Ahn., 2007, A Study on Factors Influencing the Urban Planning Consensus Building Process: Focused on the Case of Si Hwa Sustainable Development Conference, Journal of The Urban Design Institute of Korea, v.8 n.27.
  27. Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, 2008, Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project Workshop Source Book.
  28. Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, Korea Rural Community Corporation(KRC), 2007, Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project Guide Book.
  29. Moon, C. & K. K. Kim., 2006, Developing A Collaborative Governance System: Focusing on the Relocation Project of Defense Security Command, Journal of Korea Planners Association, v.41 n.6.
  30. Park, H. B. & M. H. Kim., 2000, Social Capital and Governance Capacity in Local Community, Korean Public Administration Review, v.34 Issue.4.
  31. Park, H. S. & G. S. Hwang., Y. T. Kim., 2008, Contents Analysis on the Rural Village Development Projects: With Focus on Project Regions during 2004-2007, Journal of Korea Society of Rural Planning, v.14 n.4.
  32. Song, M. R. & J. I. Seong., 2004, Evaluation of Rural Village Development Programs and Suggestions for Participatory Village Development Model, Korea Rural Economic Institute.
  33. Suh, S. T. & B. K. Min., 2005, A Study in Collaborative Governance for Reginal Development, Journal of the Korean Regional Development Association, v.30 n.2.
  34. Suh, S. T., 2002, The Role and Task of Urban Planning for Building Social Capital: Approaches and Policy Implications, The Korea Spatial Planning Review, v.33.
  35. Yeom, I. Y., 2008, A study on Using the Collaborative Planning Process of the Sihwa-Lake Development Project, The Ph. D. thesis at the University of Seoul.

Cited by

  1. A Relative Importance Evaluation for the Perception of Managers on the Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project using Analytic Hierarchy Process vol.21, pp.1, 2015, https://doi.org/10.7851/ksrp.2015.21.1.041
  2. 농촌 공동체 협업활동의 사회연결망분석 - 충남 홍성군 홍동 지역을 중심으로 - vol.23, pp.2, 2014, https://doi.org/10.7851/ksrp.2017.23.2.009
  3. 지역대학생의 농촌경관 개선사업 참여를 위한 발전방안 연구 - 금산읍 농촌중심지 사업을 대상으로 - vol.24, pp.2, 2018, https://doi.org/10.7851/ksrp.2018.24.2.091
  4. 읍·면 소재지 종합정비사업의 성과경로 분석 vol.25, pp.2, 2014, https://doi.org/10.7851/ksrp.2019.25.2.047
  5. Director Opinion on Community Competence: Evidence from Management Organizations of the Rural Community Support Project in South Korea vol.10, pp.6, 2020, https://doi.org/10.3390/agriculture10060202