Journal of the Korea Institute of Building Construction (한국건축시공학회지)

The Korean Institute of Building Construction (한국건축시공학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Study on the Newly Recognized Defect Factors in Defect Lawsuits of Apartment Housing

공동주택 하자소송단계에서의 하자인정항목에 관한 연구

  • Received : 2020.09.29
  • Accepted : 2020.11.19
  • Published : 2020.12.20
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study proposes additional items to be recognized as defects in a defect lawsuit through a case analysis of lawsuit cases in apartment housing. Identifying these defects prevents an unexpected increase in litigation costs, delays in the date of litigation, and emotion repercussions or additional lawsuits. In this study, the defects that were not discovered by the existing occupants and construction companies, but were newly discovered in litigation, were defined as defects in lawsuits. Fifteen cases of lawsuits were analyzed and a total of 77 defects were derived. Each item was then reviewed for location, work type, number of occurrences, and cost. The results were yielded 23 defect items, which were validated by appraisers who directly appraised the cases. In addition, the derived defect factors were analyzed. Finally, the 23 defect items were categorized into 10 main factors which include attributes such as causes of occurrence and characteristics. This can provide an overall area of defects to be considered in addition to existing defect items in the life cycle of the housing. The results of this study can contribute to reducing the actual occurrence of defects and minimizing the disputes in the case of defect lawsuits.

본 연구는 공동주택의 하자소송의 사례분석을 통해 하자소송단계에서 추가적으로 하자로 인정되는 하자 항목을 제안한다. 이 하자 항목은 하자소송에서 추가적인 비용의 증가, 일정 지연, 재감정 혹은 추가소송을 방지할 수 있을 것이다. 하자소송에서는 입주자 및 건설사에서 사전에 인지하지 못한 새로운 하자항목이 발생되며, 이를 새로운 하자인정항목으로 정의하였다. 이를 위해 본 연구에서는 국내의 15개의 하자소송의 사례분석을 실시하였다. 이를 통해 77개의 소송하자를 1차 선별하고 전문가 자문을 통해 최종적으로 23개의 소송하자를 도출하였다. 이후 하자의 요인을 분석하여 최종적으로 23개의 소송항목을 총 10개의 요인항목으로 정립하였으며, 사례연구를 통해 효용성을 분석하였다. 본 연구의 결과는 하자의 발생을 저감하고 분쟁을 최소화하는 데 기여할 수 있을 것이다.

Keywords

References

  1. Lee CB. A study of methods to prevent lawsuits over the consteuction defects of a condominium. Korean Journal of Construction Legal Affairs. 2015. Dec;1:217-48.
  2. Kim YK. Contemplation on dispute resolution system and improvement plan in multi-family housing management act. Korea Institute for Condominium Buildings Law. 2019 Feb;29:1-35.
  3. Kim SW. Legal matters on the construction defect and management neglect of apartment houses. The Korean Society of Poperty Law. 2019. May;36(1):185-206. https://doi.org/10.33446/KJLS.61.7
  4. Suh HS. A study on the risk factors and management plan through analyzing the law cases of defect disputes in apartment building [dissertation]. [Gyeongsan (Korea)]: Yeungnam University; 2012. 157 p.
  5. Lee DS. Defect reduction method of apartment housing accord to change of defect management process by each work process [dissertation]. [Suwon (Korea)]: Kyonggi University; 2019. 161 p.
  6. Kim JH. A study on lawsuit against defects and method to minimize the conflicts of the apartment buildings [master's thesis]. [Daejeon (Korea)]: Chungnam National University; 2020. 47 p.
  7. Lee JO. A study on plans for reducing disputes related to defects appraisal in apartment houses [master's thesis]. [Suwon (Korea)]: Kyonggi University; 2015. 82 p.
  8. Seo YT. Causes of defect litigation of apartment and countermeasures of contractors [master's thesis]. [Busan (Korea)]: Pukyong University; 2015. 102 p.
  9. Kim ON. A study on the standard of the flaw judgment and improvement plan of condominium [master's thesis]. [Seoul (Korea)]: Kwangwoon University; 2011. 157 p.
  10. Lee KJ. A study on improvement of apartment housing defect judgment system based in judicial precedent cases [dissertation]. [Seoul (Korea)]: Hanyang University; 2014. 154 p.
  11. Jang HS. A study on the building of defect information DB management system of apartment house for defect prevention. Journal of Korean Society of Disaster Information. 2013 Sep;9(3):300-14.
  12. Lee DH, Shim UJ, Suh HS, Ahn YS. A study on the selection of primary management objects in life cycle phases through analyzing the case of defect in constructing apartment house. Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea. 2012 Jun;14(2):201-8.
  13. Lee SH, Han MC, Kim JJ, Lee JS. Analysis on characteristics of defects before inspection for apartment use. Journal of the Korea Academia Industrial cooperation Society. 2020 May; 21(5): 167-78. https://doi.org/10.5762/KAIS.2020.21.5.167
  14. Lee SH, Kim JJ, Lee SH. Evaluating importance of defects through defect dispute case study in apartment buildings. Journal of the Korea Academia Industrial cooperation Society. 2019 Mar;20(3):56-64. https://doi.org/10.5762/KAIS.2019.20.3.56
  15. Kang JG, Yoon SH. A study on the cause and prevention of defects in apartment house through case studies. Journal of Next Generation Convergence Technology Association. 2019 Jun;3(2):76-87. https://doi.org/10.33097/JNCTA.2019.03.02.76
  16. No SH. An Analysis on the defect risks in apartment building based on defect lawsuit case study [master's thesis]. [Seoul (Korea)]: Hanyang University; 2018. 55 p.
  17. Son YS. Study on defects before completion of mass housing defect lawsuit appraisal categories [master's thesis]. [Seoul (Korea)]: Kwangwoon University; 2010. 99 p.
  18. Park JM, Seok DS, Choi JH, Kim OK, Park KW, Jo JH. Analysis on legal issue of lawsuits and subjective judgment on defects in apartment building. Journal of Korea Institute of Building Construcion. 2012 Oct;12(1):42-53. https://doi.org/10.5345/JKIBC.2012.12.1.042
  19. Shin MY. A study on countermeasures of the sectional owners for the unconsteucted or modified parts on construction drawings. The Journal of Legal Studies. 2017 Jul;25(3):91-111.
  20. Lee HR. A study on liability for defect repair and damage of collective residential building. Korea Institute for Condominium Buildings Law. 2015 Jun;15:65-102. https://doi.org/10.5345/JKIBC.2015.15.1.065
  21. Shin BG. The trend of precedents about the deficiency liability of a condominium. Korean Law Association. 2012 May;46:143-68.
  22. Kim SW. Civil liability in connection with the defect of the common sector in apartment houses. Korea Institute for Condominium Buildings Law. 2019 May;30:1-30.
  23. Yu BS. A study for legal issues and improvement plan of defect liability in apartment houses;focusing on precedents of defect lawsuit [dissertation]. [Seoul (Korea)]: Kwangwoon University; 2018. 277 p.
  24. Yoon WS. The status and countermeasures of defect law suit solutions of apartment buildings [master's thesis]. [Suwon (Korea)]: Ajou University; 2011. 63 p.
  25. Kim KH. A study on the apartments defect lawsuits and disputes prevention by analyzing judicial precedents [master's thesis]. [Seoul (Korea)]: Hanyang University; 2020. 78 p.
  26. Jeon SJ. A study on the design improvements based on the defect-survey of apartment [master's thesis]. [Suwon (Korea)]: Kyonggi University; 2010. 112 p.
  27. Lee HJ. A study on defects occurrence and preventive measures in apartment building construction [master's thesis]. [Seoul (Korea)]: Hanyang University; 2011. 71 p.
  28. Lee GW. A study on countermeasure and analysis defect factor of construction in apartment housing [master's thesis]. [Chuncheon (Korea)]: Kangwon University; 2015. 112 p.
  29. Yu MH. The study on the causes of defect &reduction measure of the apartment house [master's thesis]. [Daegu (Korea)]: Daegu University; 2010. 58 p.
  30. Lee DW. A study on the defect reduction methods through the analysis of defect information in apartment houses [master's thesis]. [Suwon (Korea)]: Kyonggi University; 2017. 101 p.
  31. Song KM. A study on analysis of defect cause and countermeasure of apartment house [master's thesis]. [Chuncheon (Korea)]: Kangwon National University; 2013. 103 p.
  32. Lee JE. A study on the defect reduction method through analyzing the defects pattern of apartment; with the point of cost [master's thesis]. [Gangneung (Korea)]: Kwandong University; 2009. 80 p.
  33. You YW. An analytic study on influencing factors of maintenance costs in apartment housing by defect claim precedents [master's thesis]. [Cheongju (Korea)]: Chungbuk National University; 2010. 82 p.
  34. Lee SH. Occurance probability and cost of residential building defects analysed from dispute cases [dissertation]. [Seoul (Korea)]: Hanyang University; 2020. 196 p.