A Study of stability in ratings for clothing styles

의복스타일에 따른 평가의 재현성 차이에 관한 연구

  • 유경숙 (군산대학교 생활과학부)
  • Published : 2003.08.01

Abstract

The aim of the present study was to measure intra-individual consistency in clothing style evaluation and to examine its relation to the ratings. For this study, a pilot test was conducted to 50 clothing majored university students to explore the stimulus of‘cute’,‘casual’,‘sexy’,‘elegant’,‘intelligent’,‘formal’,‘romantic’,‘individual’,‘refined’for the 9 each image styles from the 32 spring wears in fashion magazine$\boxDr$FARBE$\boxUl$(March, 2000). On the basis of the preliminary survey, the question items explored the 15 pairs of bipolar adjectives as seven-point Likert type. The main survey was preceded 94 female and 111 men of university students from March 13 to 24 in 2000, twice for 7-days interval. As a result of analyzing of correlation coefficients between the two ratings for each subjects, intra-individual consistency in the evaluation, ranged from -.11 to .87 and mean coefficient was .64 of female and .20 to .76 and mean coefficient was .57 of male. Female had higher intra-individual consistency in the evaluation than male. Based on the coefficients, the subjects were classified into three groups: high, medium, and low intra-individual consistency. Analysis of variance of mean ratings by the three groups revealed that significant difference existed in 42% of female and 25% of male in 135 combinations of 9 clothing and 15 semantic differential scales. There was an apparent tendency that subjects of female with high intra-individual consistency were mostly definitely to evaluate clothing, whereas the ones with low were least. But male shows opposit trend compare to each groups of female. The result of this study, it was found that female rated higher intra-individual consistency and definition in the two times evaluations than male and among the semantic differential scales'consistency differ depending on style and gender. It is believed that the result of this study is helpful clothing image evaluation, and clothing image selection tendency.

Keywords

References

  1. ?양대학교 대학원 박사 학위 논문 Texture와 Colour Coordination의 감성공학적 Technology에 관한 연구 김미미자
  2. 한국의류학회지 v.23 no.8 셀룰라아제 처리된 데님직물의 태에 관한 연구(제1보)-주관적인 태 평가를 위한 척도개발- 김경애(외)
  3. 한국의류학회지 v.24 no.7 의복디자인의 조형적 특성에 따른 감성연구 김유진;이경희
  4. 한국의류학회지 v.24 no.6 의복무늬의 시각적 감성연구 김윤경;이경희
  5. 한국의류학회지 v.24 no.5 남자 중 · 고등학생의 자기이미지와 의복추구 이미지에 대한 연구 문미아;박혜선
  6. 한국의류학회지 v.26 no.6 현대패션에 나타난 노랑의조형성과 이미지 오해순;이경희
  7. 한국의류학회지 v.25 no.3 의복과 그 직물에대한 평가의 재현성 차이에 관한 연구 유경숙
  8. 한국의류학회지 v.25 no.3 패션감성의 측정도구 개발에 관한 연구(제1보) 이경희
  9. 한국의류학회지 v.25 no.5 패션감성과 의복조형의 관계연구 이경희;이유진
  10. 한국의류학회지 v.26 no.6 의복배색의 시각적 감성연구 은소영(외)
  11. Psychiatry Research v.65 no.3 The Children's affective lability scale: A psychometric evaluation of reliability Gerson,A.C.;Gerring,J.P.;Freund,L.;Joshi,P.
  12. International Journal of methods in psychiatric Research v.6 no.1 Barnes Akathisia Scale. Usefulness of standardized videotape method in evaluation of reliability and in training raters Inada,T.;Matuda,G.;Kitao,Y. https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1234-988X(199604)6:1<49::AID-MPR152>3.3.CO;2-7
  13. Perception and Motor Skills v.64 Individual differences in fashion orientation and cognitive complexity Lennon,J.S.;Davis,L.L.
  14. Journal of General Psychology v.119 no.1 Does memory contaminate test retest reliability Mckelvie,S.J. https://doi.org/10.1080/00221309.1992.9921158
  15. Home Economic Research Journal v.10 Measurement of individual difference in sensitivity to appearance Miller,G.F.;Freinberg,A.R.;Davis,L.L.;Rowold,L.K. https://doi.org/10.1177/1077727X8201000409
  16. Educational Psychological Measurement v.14 Test-retest effect on personality questionnaires Windle,C. https://doi.org/10.1177/001316445401400404
  17. Educational Psychological Measurement v.15 Further studies of test-retest effect on personality questionnaires Windle,C. https://doi.org/10.1177/001316445501500304
  18. 日本纖維機械學會 v.50 no.10 服裝評價におけるあぃまぃきの檢討 福井典代;近藤信子;藤原康晴
  19. 日本纖維機械學會誌 v.48 no.4 服裝によって生起すゐ多面的感情狀態尺度の作成 西藤榮子;中川草苗;藤原康晴
  20. 日本纖維機械學會誌 v.49 no.8 服裝に對すゐ評價とその服裝によって生起する多面的感情 狀態との關係 西原容以(外9人)
  21. 敎育心理學硏究 v.24 質問紙性格檢査の再檢査效果 迪水敏彦
  22. 敎育心理學硏究 v.25 再檢査效果につぃての一硏究 迪水敏彦
  23. 心理學硏究 v.49 no.3 大學生におる再檢査效果の生起 迪水敏彦
  24. 心理學硏究 v.66 no.2 自己評價の水準と項目評價性が再檢査效果に及ほす影響 長谷川博一
  25. 心理學硏究 v.68 no.5 再檢査效果と項目再認識記憶の關係につぃて 長谷川博一
  26. セソソリ一ェパリュェ一ツョン一官能檢査へのぃざなぃ一 增山英太郞;小林茂雄