Development of An Evaluation System for the Interim Check of Integrated Rural Village Development Project

농촌마을종합개발사업 중간 점검을 위한 평가지표 적용사례

  • Han, Kyung-Soo (Rural Research Institute, Korea Rural Community & Agriculture Corporation) ;
  • Kim, Ki-Hyun (Rural Research Institute, Korea Rural Community & Agriculture Corporation) ;
  • Jun, Teak-Ki (Rural Research Institute, Korea Rural Community & Agriculture Corporation) ;
  • Um, Dae-Ho (Rural Research Institute, Korea Rural Community & Agriculture Corporation) ;
  • Choi, Youn-Sang (For AG)
  • 한경수 (한국농촌공사 농어촌연구원) ;
  • 김기현 (한국농촌공사 농어촌연구원) ;
  • 전택기 (한국농촌공사 농어촌연구원) ;
  • 엄대호 (한국농촌공사 농어촌연구원) ;
  • 최윤상 (포애그컨설팅)
  • Published : 2007.06.30

Abstract

In this study, We developed an evaluation system for the interim check of Integrated Rural Village Development Project and analyzed its applicability to an actual evaluation process through a pilot evaluation on regions selected. The evaluation system consists of documentary assessments(30%) and field inspections(70%). The documentary assessments are quantitative assessments on check-lists reports by self-evaluation prepared by local governments. The field inspections are qualitative assessments by evaluation teams. Sixteen evaluation indices were developed for documentary assessments and seven criteria were designed for field inspections. For a pilot evaluation, one region in each province excluding Jeju Do, eight regions was selected and the field inspections due to circumstances was proceeded in two regions. The results of documentary assessments indicate that most of regions are evaluated low in project performance attributable to the delay in security for sites. In the field inspections, it appears that most of the regions evaluated high at the documentary assessments got a high point from them. They also show that coordination of action plans, rather than quantitative achievements, is a base determining success of the projects.

Keywords

References

  1. 갈렙앤컴퍼니, 2003, 농촌진흥사업 성과지표 개발 보고서
  2. 건설교통부, 2004, 지역개발사엽 관리정보화시스템 구축 및 개발촉진지구 평가지침작성에 관한 연구
  3. 국토연구원, 2002, 국토계획평가체계구축방안연구
  4. 김건영, 강경우, 2002, AHP를 이용한 서울시 소화물일관운송 공동집배송센터 입지선정에 관한 연구, 국토계획 37(3) : 65-76
  5. 김정호, 김경석, 정진규, 2002, SOC 투자지표 개발 에 관한 연구: AHP기법을 통한 투자지표 설정방향을 중심으로, 국토연구원
  6. 농어촌진흥공사, 농어촌연구원, 1999, 문화마을조성 사업 사후평가 및 발전방안 연구
  7. 서교 동,2006, DEA와 AHP를 이용한 농촌건강장수 마을사업 평가모형 개발, 농촌계획 12(4) : 1-12
  8. 엄대호 둥, 2006, BSC에 의한 농촌마을 그린투어리즘 성과지표 개발에 관한 연구, 농촌계획 12(3) : 43-55
  9. 오윤경 둥, 2007, 농촌어메니티자원조사 연구, 농촌계획 13(1) : 1-10
  10. 이동근 동, 농촌어메니티 자원에 기초한 농촌경관 평가에 관한 연구, 농촌계획 14(1) : 11-18
  11. 입창수 둥, 2006, 농촌마을 수준에서의 어메니티 강화 및 저해요소 항목체계 구축, 농촌계획 12(4) : 89-97
  12. 한경수, 1999, 농촌마을수준의 지역자원 평가시스템 개발, 전남대학교 박사학위논문
  13. 한국개발연구원,2000, 사후적 사업평가제도 도입을 위한 기초연구
  14. 한국지방행정연구원, 1999, 지방자치단체 지역개발 사업의 평가체계 및 기법개발